People · · 1 min read
Why the same evidence leads to different answers
A note on mental models, curiosity and the assumptions hidden inside a disagreement.
Expanded from my Telegram note. The English edition is a translation and editorial adaptation.
I used to find it strange that two people could look at the same situation and reach very different conclusions. Years of mathematics can make a single path to a single answer feel natural.
Learning about mental models gave me another way to approach that surprise. We interpret events through experience, beliefs and assumptions. What looks obvious to me may depend on background that another person does not share.
Find the assumption
In a discussion about a product metric, one person might care about short-term conversion while another worries about repeat use. Their disagreement may begin before either of them reads the chart: they have different ideas about what success means.
Asking which time horizon or customer behavior each person is considering can make that disagreement more specific.
Include yourself
The exercise is not only about explaining other people. Write down your own expectation before looking at the result. Which assumption would need to change for you to interpret the result differently?
I mentioned Mohammadreza Shabanali’s discussion of mental models on the channel because it encouraged this kind of reflection. The useful habit is to stay curious about how someone arrived at a view, while remaining willing to examine the evidence together.